Which tool to choose? An evaluation of the design and implementation of healthy planning frameworks in the UK

A healthy planning framework in action. Photo: Caitlin Ball, Healthy Cities

With so many different forms of guidance available for incorporating health into planning, our study evaluated what makes a healthy planning framework successful.

Share

Target audience

Healthy urban planners, Public Health, urban planners.

The problem

While there are a wide number of frameworks and tools to support the integration of health into urban planning available, they have not yet been systematically evaluated.

What we did and why

We conducted a systematic appraisal, made up of desk research and semi-structured interviews, of seven healthy planning frameworks designed for use in the UK. We used this to identify information on the challenges and best practices for healthy planning framework design and implementation.

Our study’s contribution

Shared challenges, best practices, and considerations for success were identified around the following themes: framework design & conceptualisation, framework recommendations & content, implementation outcomes & impact, framework evaluations, and other more general challenges.

Impacts for city policy and practice

Our results include several key considerations for practitioners in health and planning to include when designing healthy planning guidance, frameworks, or tools. The results are also useful for practical implementation of tools, and we include recommendations on outcome evaluation of applying healthy planning frameworks.

Further information

This UN-Habitat/WHO Sourcebook provides a useful mapping of existing health planning frameworks: WHO webpage.

Full research article:

A thematic analysis of UK healthy planning frameworks and tools designed to support the inclusion of health in urban planning by Amber De La Haye, Ruth Gow, Amelia Lake, Caitlin Ball, Sebastiaan van Herk, Marta Rofin Serra, Andy Jones, Michael Chang and Helen Moore.

Related posts

Boxed in: Changes in apartment residents’ health behaviours following the COVID-19 lockdown – a longitudinal cohort study from Australia

This study adds to the literature on the health impacts of lockdowns by examining longitudinal changes in the health behaviours of Australian apartment residents. Following the COVID-19 lockdown, residents reported increased walking for recreation, sleep duration, and home cooking frequency, but decreased walking for transport, greater sitting time, and weight gain. Alcohol consumption remained stable.

Read More »